So, the discussion gets as heated as the armchair is uncomfortable!
Here we sit with perfect hindsight and have as many opinions as there are people reading the topic.
Me, I think that all the years of experience, together with a dollop of good fortune saved the day!
There is simply no way that the PIC, as hot as they may deem themselves to be, is going to attempt this sort of maneuvre, knowing that this could be a terminal excercise. (Bin Laden's sidekicks excluded)
My own rule for me (but you are welcome to adapt this for you too ) is not to critize the PIC in a crash or event such as this ... you see, I could have made worse calls if I were in their shoes.
My happiness stems from the fact that all survived and we have a video to see the buckets full of luck being dished out to all aboard. Those people don't have to play the LOTTO for awhile, they have used it all up
I hope to have as much skill & luck when this comes my way ... and you fine folks may fill the pages of the net with opions, I'll just consider my enormous amount of luck as I sit back to enjoy another day on this earth