Ok, I'm not sure if I am walking into a hornets nest, but here goes....
I think the arguments that the cozy is a proven design and has an excellent track record is very compelling evidence that you probably will never need to deploy a BRS because of an in-flight structural failure. Kudos to Burt and Nat, from what I have seen and read it's a very safe design.
But...The quest for a system that would bring an aircraft to the ground with a reasonably good chance for the pilot and passengers to survive is, in my opinion, a legitimate thing to look at. In my mind (not a big place), there are situations that pilots get themselves into that cannot be gotten out of. The fact is that pilots are human and make mistakes. I can't think of anyone that wants to or expects to spring a fuel leak over a rugged mountain range. Or intentionally finds themselves in a situation where they are above the clouds with no recourse other than to descend IFR down into severe terrain. Would anyone willingly take off in an aircraft with their wife and kids in the passenger seats if they knew that they were 45 minutes from their first heart attack, stroke, acute food poisoning, etc? Freak turbulence? Unanticipated severe Icing? Think these situations were avoidable? Yes of course, most of them are, but pilots still find themselves in these situations. I've spent the majority of my adult life dealing with and learning to deal with extremely dangerous situations and if there is one thing that has become apparent to me it is that highly qualified and prepared people can still make mistakes and or bear the brunt of Murphy’s law. I’ve lost several friends this way.
Now, that being said, would I use a BRS? Probably not, But I would love to see someone do it. Who knows, maybe the technology will come in to its own over the years. It would also give us a great deal to talk about .
Side note: I read the other day in Kitplanes about the Mystere S-45 pusher having a BRS on its underbelly. Here is a quote:
The article also makes it sound as if there is only one main attach point located right above the CG. I’m not suggesting that, because it was done in this case, it would be wise or easy to do it in a Cozy however.
Anyway, just thought I would throw that out there for discussion.
Jake