|

Before using the Don Bates model to define the
propeller for my "Kinda Kozy" I wanted to carry out a couple of
sanity checks since I found that it was possible to arrive at a wide range
of propeller designs when using his model. To this end I chose to estimate
the pitch using more conventional methods thus providing a level of
confidence once the model was implemented.
The first inputs result from the estimate for maximum
speed in the cruise condition. This was derived from the assumption that
the RG gave a speed increase of at least 14 mph. This resulted in a top
cruise speed of 230 mph. This would be achieved using a Lycoming 0-360
(180 hp) engine through a fixed pitch propeller. The SVX engine in its
stock form provides 230 hp and since I have no knowledge of the expected
power with the small number of induction and exhaust changes, I assume
that the power is unchanged.
The expected speed of an aircraft, in which the
dominant drag is parasitic drag, increases with the cube root of the power
so the expected speed with a 230 hp engine and RG should increase from 230
mph to 250 mph. To achieve this goal the propeller must have sufficient
pitch to ensure that the blade is operating within its aerodynamic drag
bucket. The drag bucket occurs when the lift to drag ratio is a maximum
and typically lies in the region of AOA = 00
to 20.
The engine spins at 5400 rpm when operating at the
maximum rated power of 230 hp. There is a reduction ratio of 1.85 : 1 in
the PSRU which reduces the output (propeller) speed to 2920 rpm. For this condition
and an advancement speed of 250 mph the helix cut by the propeller will
have a pitch of 90.4 inches. (This is the condition for incompressible
fluids or a simple screw thread.)
To achieve maximum bandwidth from the propeller the tip
speed should be as high as possible with the only limitation being that
the tip should not get into the region of aerodynamic compressibility.
Typically a figure of Mach 0.85 is used as the magic number that should
not be exceeded. (This makes some allowance for the speed increase as the
air passes over the aerofoil curved surface and the increase in air
velocity caused by the propeller operation.) Since the aircraft is moving
forwards and some air is also being moved backwards by the propeller (A
figure of 6.4 mph can be added to accommodate the induced velocity) a
forward component of velocity of 256.4 mph should be considered. The tip
velocity is at 90 degrees to the forward velocity and the full velocity
component is calculated by Pythagoras.
Alternatively, if the maximum tip speed is one of the
design criteria then the maximum radius of the propeller may be
determined:
Assuming the propeller is to be designed for an
altitude of 8000 ft, Mach 1 = 1085.3 ft sec-1
The maximum
rotational tip speed may be calculated:
With the maximum engine speed of 5400 rpm spinning the
propeller at 2920 rpm the maximum radius to achieve this goal may be
calculated by re-arranging the relationship:
- 2 p R
RPM = Rotational Tip Speed
- R = Rotational
Tip Speed / (2 p
RPM)
- R = 33.1 inches
Thus the propeller should be no greater than 66 inches
in diameter.
The 90.4 inch helix requirement and the propeller
diameter result in an angle of attack or pitch angle as a function of
blade station. This relationship is indicated graphically below. Notice
how steep the blade angle is, even at the tip which is why the take off
performance is expected to be not too good.

Application
of Don Bates model with the data gathered from previous characterization
and a free choice of prop diameter yield
|
CONTROL |
| NPAYOFF |
2 |
| IOPT |
1, 3, 5, 6, 7 |
| AIRFOIL |
2 |
| BLDOP |
0 |
| HUBFLG |
0 |
| PDES |
1 |
| |
|
| |
|
|
| DESLIM |
| ABMIN |
2.5 |
| AFLIM |
60, 150 |
| CLDES |
0.4 |
| DMAX |
68.0 |
| RCLM |
1000 |
| REDLIM |
1, 4 |
| TPMMAX |
0.850 |
| WPLIM |
400, 950 |
|
|
DESVAR |
| ADRAG |
1.681156795381767 |
| AFDES |
70.22299794772854 |
| ALTCRS |
8000 |
| ALTCLM |
3000 |
| ALTSRF |
0 |
| KS |
1 |
| DIAM |
64 |
| DREF |
64 |
| NB |
3 |
| OSWALD |
0.851 |
| PCTPWR |
100 |
|
| PITCH |
81.22965952638434 |
| REDFAC |
1.85 |
| RPMCLM |
4339.396222277926 |
| RPMCRS |
5400.000000000000 |
| SFCLM |
0 |
| SFCRS |
10 |
| SPAN |
28 |
| VCLM |
128.1309305082813 |
| VCRS |
245.2487632164967 |
| WPAYLD |
400 |
| WT0 |
1100 |
|
|
Output data, from the program is given below. The
equivalent flat plate drag has reduced from the nominal 2 ft2
to a value of 1.681 ft2.
This is a substantial improvement over the stock Cozy MK IV.
|
PROPELLER DESIGN CRUISE PERFORMANCE @ 8000 MSL |
| NUMBER OF BLADES |
3 |
| BLADE ACTIVITY FACTOR |
70.22 |
| DIAMETER, INCHES |
64.00 |
| GEOMETRIC PITCH, IN |
81.23 |
| EFFECTIVE PITCH, IN |
88.73 |
| ABSOLUTE PITCH, IN |
99.99 |
| BLADE ANGLE DEG @75%R |
33.55 |
| ALPHA @ 0LL DEG @75%R |
3.07 |
| DESIGN LIFT COEF, CL |
0.400 |
| THRUST COEF, CT |
0.0612 |
| POWER COEF, CP |
0.1020 |
| ADVANCE RATIO, J |
1.3863 |
| EFFICIENCY, ETA |
0.8311 |
| ETA COMPRESS CORRECT |
0.00% |
| ETA PROFILE DRAG CORR |
0.27% |
| ETA DIAMETER CORRECT |
0.00% |
| SLIPSTREAM COEF, KS |
1.0000 |
| ADRAG, SQ FT |
1.681 |
| GROSS WEIGHT, LB |
1500.0 |
| WPAYLD, LB |
400.0 |
|
| VELOCITY, MPH |
245.25 |
| THRUST, POUNDS |
218.89 |
| DRAG, POUNDS |
218.89 |
| THRUST HP |
143.15 |
| SHAFT HP |
172.25 |
| HP AVAILABLE |
172.25 |
| PROPELLER RPM |
2918.92 |
| ENGINE RPM |
5400 |
| REDUCT FACTOR |
1.85 |
| PARASITE DRAG,LB |
203.53 |
| INDUCED DRAG, LB |
8.88 |
| SLIPSTREAM DRAG |
6.48 |
| SFC, LB/HP/HR |
0.54 |
| MILES/GALLON |
18.98 |
| FUEL FLOW, GPH |
12.92 |
| SOUND SPEED,FPS |
1085.32 |
| TIP SPEED, FPS |
890.95 |
| TIP MACH NUMBER |
0.82 |
| CAFE CHALLENGE |
883325 |
| |
|
|
My estimate of 90 inches for the Effective pitch
|
CLIMB PERFORMANCE AT V= 128.13 MPH & 3000 MSL |
| NUMBER OF BLADES |
3 |
| BLADE ACTIVITY FACTOR |
70.22 |
| DIAMETER, INCHES |
64.00 |
| EFFECTIVE PITCH, IN |
57.68 |
| BLADE ALPHA DEG @75%R |
12.61 |
| BLADE LIFT COEF, CL |
1.2701 |
| PROPELLER RPM |
2345.62 |
| THRUST COEF, CT |
0.1385 |
| POWER COEF, CP |
0.1651 |
| ADVANCE RATIO, J |
0.9013 |
| EFFICIENCY, ETA |
0.7560 |
| ETA COMPRESS CORRECT. |
0.00% |
| ETA PROFILE DRAG CORR |
0.05% |
| ETA DIAMETER CORRECT. |
0.00% |
| ADRAG, SQ FT |
1.684 |
|
| CLIMB RATE, FPM |
2021.23 |
| THRUST, POUNDS |
372.53 |
| DRAG, POUNDS |
103.65 |
| THRUST HP |
127.29 |
| SHAFT HP |
168.37 |
| HP AVAILABLE |
168.37 |
| ENGINE RPM |
4339.40 |
| PARASITE DRAG,LB |
64.67 |
| INDUCED DRAG, LB |
27.95 |
| SLIPSTREAM DRAG |
11.03 |
| GROSS WEIGHT, LB |
1500.00 |
| SOUND SPEED,FPS |
1104.88 |
| TIP SPEED, FPS |
681.45 |
| TIP MACH NUMBER |
0.62 |
|
|
|
|
FIXED PITCH STATIC PERFORMANCE AT SURFACE ALTITUDE= 0. FT |
| STATIC PROPELLER RPM |
2230.96 |
| STATIC ENGINE RPM |
4127.28 |
| THRUST COEF, CT |
0.1557 |
|
| STATIC THRUST LB |
414.02 |
| SHAFT HP |
177.06 |
| IDEAL THRUST @75%HP |
413.74 |
|
With a static thrust of 414 lbs the take off
roll is expected to be approximately 1000ft with a 1500lb gross weight.
Last Updated:
Thursday August 31, 2006
|